ClickCease

Results for unjustified disadvantage

Showing 49-56 of 171 results
Jennifer Jacobsen v Cube Innovations Limited [2026] NZERA 356 - invalid trial period, no notice, and dismissal by email

Jennifer Jacobsen was dismissed by email only days into part-time work for Cube Innovations. Cube relied on a 90-day trial even though the evidence indicated she had started work before signing the agreement and the employer had not given the contractual notice required by the clause.

Matched passage: Unjustified disadvantage: training claim failed, written-reasons claim succeeded Ms Jacobsen also claimed unjustified disadvantage.
Deborah Eyles v Bottlers Limited [2026] NZERA 300 - no redundancy process, unexplained stand down and dismissal; $20,000 compensation ordered

Deborah Eyles was stood down from her supervised-contact work and later dismissed in circumstances the employer characterised as redundancy. She challenged both the unexplained removal from work and the absence of any genuine consultation or fair redundancy process.

Matched passage: Mrs Eyles established a personal grievance for unjustified dismissal.
TONG v SHEFFIELD STEEL SERVICES LIMITED and Anor [2025] NZERA 460 - employer conduct caused constructive dismissal

Mr Tong's claims against Sheffield Steel arose after workplace difficulties, attempts to place him with another employer and the eventual end of his employment. He alleged both unjustified disadvantage and constructive dismissal.

Matched passage: Later, Mr Tong's grievance claims Claims for unjustified disadvantage and unjustified dismissal [20] Mr Tong's closing submissions did not differentiate which alleged facts supported each of his grievance claims.
Nicholas Gordon Pilcher v Brandt Tractor Limited [2026] NZERA 273 - dismissal for untested bullying complaints held unjustified; de facto suspension unjustified; $19,360 compensation + 4 months' lost pay

Brandt Tractor removed sales manager Nicholas Pilcher from the workplace on 'special leave', took his phone and laptop and then dismissed him five days later over four bullying and harassment complaints. He was not given the underlying complaints, even in redacted form, or a genuine chance to answer them.

Matched passage: ... [2026] NZERA 273 This determination is about two separate Personal Grievances (PGs): an unjustified disadvantage claim about being removed from work while complaints were "investigated", and an unjustified dismissal claim where the employer dismissed for serious misconduct ...
Emily Barr v Brooker Travel Limited [2026] NZERA 651 - bullying complaint failures led to constructive dismissal

Emily Barr complained about repeated belittling and dismissive treatment by her manager. Brooker Travel obtained an external investigation but then failed to adequately protect her, disclose the final report or provide a workable return-to-work plan. The ERA found unjustified disadvantage and constructive dismissal, awarding $20,000 compensation and six months' lost wages with associated entitlements.

Matched passage: ... travel consultant Employment commenced: 10 November 2023 Resigned: 30 April 2025 Outcome: unjustified disadvantage and unjustified constructive dismissal Compensation: $20,000 Lost wages: $16,498.56 gross Holiday pay: $1,319.56, plus employer KiwiSaver contributions and ...
ORMSBY v BLUELAGOON NZ LIMITED [2025] NZERA 44 - Messenger dismissal for inability to pay; wages and compensation awarded

BlueLagoon ended Mr Ormsby's employment by Messenger after the employer said it could no longer afford to pay him. The case also involved unpaid wages, holiday pay and KiwiSaver obligations alongside the dismissal grievance.

Matched passage: Practical takeaways Unjustified disadvantage claims require both unjustified conduct and actual disadvantage.
WATSON v ALCHEMY BUILDERS LIMITED and Anor [2025] NZERA 265 - disadvantage claim fails but dismissal grievance succeeds

Mr Watson challenged a written warning and later alleged he was constructively dismissed after his relationship with Alchemy Builders deteriorated and he was removed from a workplace WhatsApp group. Timeliness affected the earlier disadvantage grievance.

Matched passage: ... 2025 Determination date: 13 May 2025 Outcome: The Authority ordered remedies and addressed unjustified dismissal issues. Story in plain English The Authority ordered remedies and addressed unjustified dismissal issues. In summary, Second, he alleged he was unjustifiably ...
Juliet Hull v Sleaktek Limited and Robert Lawrence [2026] NZERA 579 - CEO wins dismissal and disadvantage claims

Sleaktek stopped paying chief executive Juliet Hull, pursued a redundancy process she said was predetermined and later raised serious-misconduct allegations that had not been fairly put to her. The case also concerned director Robert Lawrence's personal involvement.

Matched passage: ... Role: chief executive Dismissal: 11 June 2024 Determination: 21 August 2026 Outcome: unjustified dismissal and unjustified disadvantage Compensation: $45,000 Lost remuneration: $50,000 gross Arrears, notice and holiday pay: $86,123.02 gross Penalties: $8,500 in total ...

Browse topics